Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Public Service Commission aide fired... admits to sharing codes with a FPL executive.


http://www.miamiherald.com/news/southflorida/story/1221290.html?story_link=email_msg

Public Service Commission aide fired over codes
A state utility regulator fired her aide after the aide admits to sharing BlackBerry codes with a Florida Power & Light executive.

BY MARY ELLEN KLAS
HERALD/TIMES TALLAHASSEE BUREAU

TALLAHASSEE -- Public Service Commissioner Nancy Argenziano, who has criticized her agency for being too close to the utilities it regulates, fired her top aide Sunday after he admitted to giving the private messaging code for his BlackBerry to a Florida Power & Light executive.

Larry Harris, 40, who has been at the PSC since 2001, volunteered to resign and seek a job elsewhere in the PSC after Argenziano read a Miami Herald story online late Saturday revealing that at least three PSC aides had given the messaging codes to an FPL executive. Harris worked as a senior attorney at the PSC before joining Argenziano's staff in 2007. He said he has no guarantee that he will find a new PSC job.

The Herald/Times has reported that the messaging codes -- called Personal Identification Numbers, or PINS -- had been given to FPL attorney Natalie Smith, potentially allowing the utility to communicate directly with commissioners outside public view and without leaving a paper trail.

Documents obtained by the Herald/Times also showed that at least one staff aide, Roberta Bass, who works with Commissioner Lisa Edgar, gave FPL the message code to Edgar's BlackBerry. The PSC is currently being investigated by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement for possible ethics violations.

Harris said he told Argenziano that Smith had contacted the top advisors to all five PSC commissioners in 2008 to ask for their PINS. He gave it to the FPL attorney, he said, because he believed the PIN "was a public record, just as with any other state-issued device.''

He said he also told Smith that Argenziano had a strict policy forbidding him from communicating in any fashion with utility representatives. "I told Natalie, Commissioner Argenziano's position was very clear -- I was not to talk to anyone who is regulated,'' Harris told the Herald/Times.

State law prohibits PSC commissioners from discussing a pending rate case with utility officials but it specifically excludes PSC staff from the ban. PSC officials told the Herald/Times that it does not save PIN messages.

Miami media law expert Tom Julin said that the PSC's failure to keep a record of the PIN messages sent via staff BlackBerrys could be a violation of the state's public records law.

Harris said Smith was the only utility representative who asked for his PIN number and he said he doesn't recall ever receiving a message from her.

Argenziano said she was disappointed in Harris but thought he understood the guidelines. "He's not a bad person,'' she said. "But why would you let a utility person do that?''

Another PSC commissioner, Nathan Skop, told the Herald/Times Sunday that he had a standing policy in his office not to give out PIN numbers to regulated utilities. "To the best of my knowledge, neither my aide nor I have every given it out to a regulated entity,'' he said.

Documents given to the Herald/Times showed that Commission Chairman Matthew Carter's aide, William Garner, had given out Garner's PIN and Edgar's aide had given out the aide's PIN as well. Carter told the Herald/Times that he was not aware that his aide's PIN had been shared with FPL. Edgar said she was not aware of receiving any PIN messages from Smith. Commissioner Katrina McMurrian, nor her aide, Lorena Holley, could be reached for comment.

Mary Ellen Klas can be reached at meklas@MiamiHerald.com.


Similar Stories:
[click links below for full story]
•Public Service Commission lobbyist steps down
In the last two weeks:
-The Florida Department of Law Enforcement began investigating the PSC for potential ethics violations.

-The Herald/Times revealed that an FPL executive had asked for and received private BlackBerry messaging codes for one commissioner and two staff members, a communication method that avoids a paper trail.

- FPL executives defied a PSC order to reveal how much the company pays its top executives.

-FPL chief Armando Olivera told the PSC that his company wanted to use part of its rate increase to buy a $31 million executive jet.


• Public Service Commission lobbyist flagged for 'poor judgment'
"As state police investigate the Public Service Commission for possible ethics violations, an inspector general found Wednesday that the agency's lobbyist used "poor judgment'' and may have violated rules by attending a party at the home of a Florida Power & Light executive during a pending rate case.

Although the PSC inspector general could not prove whether lobbyist Ryder Rudd broke PSC rules on gifts and communication by attending the Kentucky Derby party, a state senator and a PSC commissioner immediately called for his ouster.

"The inexcusable conduct of this employee undermines the public trust and confidence in the regulatory process and impugns the integrity of this commission,'' Commissioner Nathan Skop wrote in a statement. "This is a clear cut ethics problem and perception issue.''

Saturday, September 5, 2009

"Training Center Similar to Venus Proposal Idea Shot Down In Ocala" and other articles on the Eagle privatized 'National Security' proposal

http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2008/jul/30/la-training-center-idea-shot-down-in-ocala/

By GARY PINNELL

Highlands Today

Published: July 30, 2008

SEBRING - A week after Seth Ellis proposed a live-fire training center near Venus, the Marion County Commission turned down a combined law enforcement and search-and-rescue facility near Ocala.

More than 200 residents packed the auditorium for the commissioner's meeting, according to a July 16 story in the Star-Banner.

Ocala Lumber President Henry J.G. Moxon tried to withdraw his application for a special use permit, but the commissioners refused his request and voted to turn down the facility, which would have a mile-long airstrip, rifle ranges, explosive storage, a vehicle track and an indoor shooting range on 2,500 acres currently zoned for agriculture use.
Moxon did not provide Marion County with details on which agencies would train there, or why aircraft would be operating there.

"That won't be very similar to what we have planned," Ellis said. "We don't have a mile-long airstrip."

His plans do include a 5,500-foot runway.

"But it may not be blacktopped," Ellis said. "It may be shell or something."

On July 15, Ellis proposed to build the Eagle National Security Training Center on 7,700 acres, near the Highlands-Glades county line.

In a written statement, Eagle proposed to locate a "first responder" facility on Southern Farms, and requested the Highlands County staff to expedite the permitting.

"Expedited permitting allows a development to speed up the state of Florida, DEP, Water Management District, etc. review process, and perhaps the county review process, said the agenda item, signed by Highlands County's chief planner, Jim Polatty, and County Administrator Michael Wright.

The resolution the county commissioners adopted said the Eagle Center would provide at least 100 full-time jobs after year three of operations, and up to 240 jobs after year five. Ellis told the commissioners the jobs could start with 250, and total 1,000.

Ellis is a CPA and the former president and CEO of ICx Digital Infrared Imaging, sensors which detect chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear and explosive weapons. He sold the company to ICx Technologies Inc. of Arlington, Va. Ellis is also a partner with GatorMezz, a fund that loans money to medium-sized, Florida-based companies.

Ellis said he was back in Highlands County last week to look over Southern Farms. Ron Eagle hired Sunshine Management, a company co-owned by Ellis, Gen. Paul Serjan and others, to plan, develop and operate the Venus project.

"We toured the property," said Ellis, speaking from a Washington airport. "We stayed at Inn on the Lakes, and had a little strategy session."

They also sketched plans for the 7,700 acres. Next, Ellis said, he must conclude financing for the project.

How much will it cost?

"A lot of zeros," Ellis said. $10 million? $100 million?

Ellis wouldn't be pinned down. "But you were a lot closer on the second figure."

Each of the five county commissioners was also contacted by the generals, said Don Bates and Edgar Stokes.

Both commissioners said they favor facility.

"So far, I'm for it," Stokes said. "It's a good thing for the county. They'll do a lot of business with the county. They'll create a lot of jobs. It's a pretty big thing. And it's way out there in the corner of the county, so it shouldn't bother anybody."

Gary Pinnell can be reached at gpinnell@highlandstoday.com or 863 386-5828
----------------------------------------

The links to other articles about this topic:

Training Center project grounded, but expected to fly
http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2009/may/29/la-training-center-project-grounded-but-expected-t/
County tries to resolve Eagle Center snafu

http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2009/jun/03/la-county-tries-to-resolve-eagle-center-snafu/
Venus neighbors to protest war games facility
http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2009/aug/14/la-venus-neighbors-to-protest-war-games-facility/
Commissioners suspend Eagle training discussion
http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2009/aug/19/la-commissioners-suspend-eagle-training-discussion/news/

County OKs expediting permit process for Eagle National July 16 2008
http://www.newssun.com/BCC-approves-expidited-permitting-of-security-center
Commissioners direct staff to work out training center plan
http://www.newssun.com/0605-eb-eagle-training
Possible zoning issues for Eagle Training Center
http://www.newssun.com/0707-eb-county-eagle-develeopment-problems
Training center foes speak to commission
http://www.newssun.com/news/0818-eb-eagle-training-center

Sunday, August 30, 2009

Take Action Oct 12-16: Global Mobilization in Defense of Mother Earth and the Peoples

On May 31, the 4th Continental Summit of Indigenous Peoples Abya Yala ("America") called for a Global Mobilization in Defense of Mother Earth and the Peoples from OCTOBER 12-16, 2009, "against [pollution], the commercialization of life ... and the criminalization of indigenous and social movements."

Root Force is supporting this call and encouraging people throughout the Americas and across the world to answer it with actions targeting the infrastructure of global trade. Infrastructure expansion projects such as roads, highways, air/sea ports, dams, power plants, pipelines and power and telecommunications cables form the front lines of the assault on indigenous peoples and the Earth. They are the backbone of the system that is killing our planet and enslaving its people.

For more information about the call to action and why we think infrastructure projects are appropriate targets, see below.

For help planning and publicizing actions, contact Root Force: rootforce [at] riseup [dot] net. You can find direct action, strategy and messaging resources here: http://www.rootforce.org/get-involved/resources/

Send action reports to rootforce [at] riseup [dot] net. If you can't pull together a direct action, consider events raising anti infrastructure awareness.

BACKGROUND

On May 31, the 4th Continental Summit of Indigenous Peoples Abya Yala issued a closing declaration resolving, among other things:

"To proclaim that we are witnessing a deep crisis of the Western capitalist civilization overlapping the environmental, energy and cultural crisis, social exclusion, and famines, as an expression of the failure of Eurocentrism and the colonialist Modernity that was born from ethnocide and which is now carrying all of humanity to its own slaughter.

"To offer an alternative lifestyle against the civilization of death, rescuing our roots in order to project ourselves to our future, with our principles and practices of balance between men, women, Mother Earth, spiritual beings, cultures and peoples, all of which we call Good Living / Living Well. We are a diversity of thousands of civilizations with over 40 thousand years of history, which were invaded and colonized by those who, just five centuries later, are leading us to planetary suicide. ...

"To confirm the organization of the ... Global Mobilization in Defense of Mother Earth and the Peoples, against the commercialization of life (including land, forests, water, sea, agrofuels, external debt), pollution (extractive transnationals, international financial institutions, GMOs, pesticides, toxic consumption), and the criminalization of indigenous and social movements, to be held from October 12 to 16, 2009."


Read the full declaration here:
http://intercontinentalcry.org/today-we-separate-from-cruelty/

WHY INFRASTRUCTURE?

There are three primary reasons to target infrastructure as a way to defend the Earth and indigenous peoples.

1. Infrastructure projects devastate ecologies and communities, whether it's the massive fish kills caused by dams and oil spills, the stripped land and poisoned air left by highways and mines, or the dislocation of poor, rural and indigenous peoples caused every time a new dam, road, mine or power plant moves in.

2. Infrastructure projects facilitate further exploitation above and beyond their immediate effects: a road brings loggers and missionaries; a power plant brings industry and sprawl.

3. Infrastructure forms the physical basis of the global economic system-- a system that is killing our planet, that cannot function without the continued dispossession of indigenous land and destruction of Earth-based
cultures.

This civilization will not change its genocidal and ecocidal trajectory willingly, and the Earth cannot be saved by half measures. The system must come down, and its reliance on infrastructure -- especially the infrastructure of trade -- is one of its greatest weaknesses.

LEARN MORE

Taking down the system by fighting infrastructure expansion:

http://www.rootforce.org/what-is-root-force/strategy/

Infrastructure and indigenous sovereignty:

http://www.rootforce.org/factsheets/indigenous/

Infrastructure and the environment:

http://www.rootforce.org/factsheets/environment/

More infrastructure fact sheets (labor, global warming, etc.):

http://www.rootforce.org/factsheets/

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

To the Florida PSC, regarding proposed FPL pipeline and rate increase

[This letter is a modified version of a 'Motion to Intervene' PBCEC filed on several fossil fuel power plants proposed for south Florida. They were rubber stamped by the Public Service Commission (PSC) in 2008 without a local public hearing. We want to express our sincere gratitude to the Florida Alliance for a Clean Environment for their support in filing grassroots interventions, as we borrowed several of their points for our letters.]

FPL Pipeline Docket 090172 and FPL rate increase Docket No. 080677-EI

The Palm Beach County Environmental Coalition opposes FPL ‘s proposed a $1.6 billion 280-mile fossil fuel (gas) pipeline across Florida, as well as the proposed $1.3 billion proposed rate increase.

We contend that when compared to other options and strategies the 280-mile FPL pipeline proposals poses an extended period of economic risk that is unreasonable and diminishes the economic well being of FPL's Florida customers now and in the future. Therefore, we request that the project be denied, pending more complete assessment of available energy options, updated growth projections and accurate complete environmental costs of burning fossil fuels.

The proposed projects do not meet the needs criteria established by the State of Florida in FS403.519(4) which require the project contribute to FPL's power system's reliability and integrity, it's fuel diversity, base load generation capacity, and its effort to deliver adequate electricity at a reasonable cost. That it continues to be a viable option after any renewable energy sources and technologies or conservation measures that may be taken or are reasonably available to FPL that might mitigate the need for the proposed fossil fuel transmission projects has been considered, while also providing the most cost effective source of power.

Florida’s electrical power grid is already over 70% dependent on gas-powered generation.

It is our contention that every dollar of FPL rate payer money proposed to be spent on the proposed fossil fuel power project could be better spent on efficiency, conservation and renewables; financing programs that may include new or expanded DSM programs, leveraging through cost sharing the expansion of net metering / distributive energy programs. The integration of solar thermal and geothermal applications can mitigate peak load. The more efficient use of the existing base load can eliminate the need for new base load capacity.

We also see a slowing of growth in Florida that calls into question the proponent's projection for need. New building design criteria is also intended to reduce the need for new fossil fuel and transmission.

We, the PBCEC, are in agreement with the report from the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council (TCRPC, or 'Council') regarding expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure. A was approved and authorized to be transmitted to the Florida Public Service Commission (PSC) on May 16, 2008, at the public Council meeting. This report found FPL to be "inconsistent with Strategic Regional Policy Plan Goal 9.1, Decreased vulnerability of the region to fuel price increases and supply interruptions; and Strategy 9.1.1, Reduce the Region's reliance on fossil fuels." The TCRPC urged FPL and the State of Florida to continue developing new programs "to 1) reduce the reliance on fossil fuels as future energy sources; 2) increase conservation activities to offset the need to construct new power plants; and 3) increase the reliance on renewable energy sources to produce electricity."

It is our belief, based on our research and the reports of the State of Florida’s TCRPC, that the projected cost of this proposal as alleged by FPL does not represent an accurate assessment of the actual costs of the project. Future costs attributed to CO2 are not taken into consideration in a tangible and concrete manner and environmental and health cost impacts associated with drilling and extraction are not mentioned. The availability and cost of water need also to be considered.

We believe that the reality of greenwashing must be taken into serious consideration when reviewing this pipeline proposal. "Greenwash" (a portmanteau of green and whitewash) is a term that is used to describe the act of misleading consumers regarding the environmental practices of a company or the environmental benefits of a product or service. The term Green sheen has similarly been used to describe organizations which attempt to appear that they are adopting practices beneficial to the environment.

While FPL's self-promotion reads, unsurprisingly, like an advertisement for their highly-profitable product. Independent, public
interest assessments of their proposals, such as that of the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council (TCRPC), reads quite differently.

The Council recommended that "FPL should develop a program to install, own and operate photovoltaic units on the rooftops of private and public buildings... modeled after the Southern California Edison plans" where a utility will plans to install solar energy on more than 100 buildings in the greater Los Angeles area. TCRPC suggests that:

"shift[ing] to rooftop photovoltaic systems distributed throughout the area of demand could reduce the reliance on large transmission lines and reduce costs associated with owning property; purchasing fuel [and water]; and permitting, constructing, and maintaining a power plant."


This above-mentioned technology is available now, and is underway in other parts of the United States.

The TCRPC report also suggests the partnering of offshore wind and ocean current generation. PBCEC believes these options, which are under development now, could be available in a hastened time frame if non-renewable conventional fuels sources were not pursued in this crucial decade, which has been acknowledged by global climate scientists to within the tipping point of irreversible climate change.

In media releases, FPL has claimed that this so-called ‘EnergySecure line’ before the PSC will reduce CO2 emissions by millions of tons over the life of its operations. But the critical eye of public interest, and public agencies that are tasked to work in its service, must also note that the project will facilitate emissions surpassing that amount on an annual basis for the duration of their operations. 'Reduction' standards must not be in the eye-of-the-profiteer. They must be concrete and tangible, measured in observance of the evolving climate science of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and other reputable scientific bodies.

The PBCEC is concerned that FPL's current agenda is not as economically sound or environmentally friendly as their public
relations would have us believe. In a letter-to-the-editor published in the Palm Beach Post following an annual FPL shareholders meeting, entitled, ironically "Conservation a top priority for industry leader FPL", Company president Armando Olivera explains FPL's perspective:

"Over-reliance on conservation to meet our needs will leave customers vulnerable to higher rates and decreased reliability."


In the face of clean, renewable energy options and efficiency and conservation opportunities, this attitude can only be seen as a threat to its customers and a leash to centralized non-renewable, unsustainable power for our FPL ratepayers in the PBCEC.

FPL’s proposed rate increases (Docket No. 080677-EI) which accompany the expansion of out-dated fossil fuel expansion and fortification of a centralized energy grid show that their priority is in maximizing company profits in violation of Florida State Statutes intend to protect the people.

We expect the Public Service Commission to follow your lawful mandate to protect our interests. Surprise us.

Most sincerely,
Panagioti Tsolkas
Co-Chair, Palm Beach County Environmental Coalition
s/panagioti tsolkas 8/26/09

Saturday, August 22, 2009

Stephanie McMillan's CODE GREEN comics


"Outside" by Stephanie McMillan
August 3rd, 2009


"Marketing" by Stephanie McMillan
August 10th, 2009

Check out South Florida artist Stephanie McMillan's new Code Green series, updated every Monday. If you print a publication or 'zine, contact Stephanie about using her art to spread the message of the environmental emergency surrounding us:
http://stephaniemcmillan.org/codegreen/