Everglades and FPL managers are evaluating a compromise so the power company can add much-needed transmission lines in West Miami-Dade.
BY TANIA VALDEMORO AND CURTIS MORGAN
tvaldemoro@MiamiHerald.com
Florida Power & Light bought a ribbon of Everglades marl prairie 40 years ago, envisioning it as an isolated place to some day run power lines.
Some day has come. FPL has filed for state permits to run three high-voltage power lines along the 7.4-mile strip.
But the surrounding land has long since been absorbed by an expansion of Everglades National Park, a federally protected wilderness where towers topping 140 feet and lines buzzing with 500 kilovolts are officially frowned upon.
Under orders from Congress, park managers are now evaluating a compromise: a land swap with FPL that would push the power corridor, now three miles west of Krome Avenue in the footprint of a critical park restoration project, to the park's eastern boundary.
For FPL, securing a western corridor for power lines is crucial, not only to handle projected population growth in Miami-Dade but also to move additional juice from the utility's planned expansion of its Turkey Point nuclear power plant. The company, already battling concerns from residents and politicians from Cutler Bay to Coconut Grove over a second proposed 230-kilovolt route up a long swath of U.S. 1, supports the swap.
''For FPL, it provides the necessary land, albeit smaller and closer to developed areas, in which to expand its electrical facilities to meet its obligation to provide reliable electric service to its customers in South Florida,'' said FPL spokesman Mayco VillafaƱa in an e-mail.
For the park, the existing corridor would complicate and potentially hinder a critical part of the massive Everglades restoration effort -- bridging Tamiami Trail to flow more water down the Northeast Shark River Slough, the park's historic and long parched headwaters.
''As long as those lands are there, there is a problem in terms of moving water to the south,'' said Dan Kimball, superintendent of Everglades National Park.
The land, only as wide as a football field, amounts to just 320 acres in the 1.5 million-acre park. But FPL would have to fill in wetlands to build bases to anchor the towers and an access road for maintainence. Towers and power lines stretching more than seven miles wouldn't exactly add to the vista, either.
CONCERNS ABOUT SWAP
Some environmentalists argue the massive transmissions lines don't belong in or along the border of a national park.
Sara Fain, Everglades program manager for the National Parks Conservation Association, said cutting a deal with the utility would set a bad precedent for handling disputes over private holdings in national parks.
''There isn't one solution, swap the land or not,'' she said. ``There is another solution. Buy the land.''
One potential alternative the park is considering is to acquire the land, by buying or condemning it, said Brien Culhane, the park's chief of planning and environmental compliance for the National Park Service.
But either option could be expensive and require time-consuming legal wrangling. FPL had discussed a land purchase for more than a decade, Kimball said. ``We couldn't agree on the terms of acquisition.''
FPL, which contends it must add power lines to improve the electrical grid and get power to growing areas, is seeking four new routes in Miami-Dade between 2012 and 2016. It has already filed permit requests for both Glades routes with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection.
VillafaƱa said the trade would benefit the park and utility, adding 60 acres to the park and removing a restoration concern. In exchange for its 320-acre strip, FPL would take over a 230-acre strip with a 90-foot easement along L31-North canal, making for easier worker access.
If the park accepts the swap, it would clear the way for easy state approval for FPL. A decision, Culhane said, is expected by January. If it rejects it, the utility could be facing another difficult fight to run lines closer to suburbia in western Dade -- perhaps along Krome Avenue.
CONGRESS' STAND
The land swap was added to a massive spending bill Congress approved in March and was supported by both Florida senators, Democrat Bill Nelson and Republican Mel Martinez.
But the clause, which passed through no committee reviews, explicitly left the final call to Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar, who oversees federal land.
It also conflicts with the congressional language supporting the park's 1989 expansion, which explicitly called power lines an incompatible use.
This time, said the park's Culhane, ``Congress authorized but did not mandate that we do an exchange. It's not a directive.''
Similar stories:
Coalition focuses on FPL plan for new U.S. 1 transmission line
A group of municipal leaders in South Miami-Dade County have banded together to discuss their concerns about the future of the U.S. 1 corridor.
Transportation and future development are their core issues.
But lately, the group, known as the South Dade Coalition, has focused on Florida Power & Light's plan to install a 230-kV transmission line along a long swath of U.S. 1 and the adjacent busway to improve the electric grid and meet future energy demands. The eastern route would connect the Turkey Point nuclear power station, located east of Homestead to a substation between Southwest First and Second avenues on the north side of the Miami River.
•
FPL's power-line plan in South Miami-Dade faces opposition
When Elizabeth Gonzalez wanted to protest against Florida Power & Light's plan to install new high-voltage transmission lines in South Miami, she turned to Facebook.
She created a group, ''Residents against FPL transmission lines,'' and provided links to FPL's project website.
In Coral Gables, Sharon Watson e-mailed and spoke to parents and students at Coral Gables Senior High School about the power lines weeks before the City Commission decided to hire a consultant in April to study how they would affect residents.
•
FPL power line proposal sparks concerns
When state regulators came to Coconut Grove Thursday night to hear from customers about Florida Power & Light's proposal to hike its base rates, they got an earful from residents and elected officials about something else: FPL's planned high-voltage transmission lines running along U.S. 1.
''If customers pay more, they should see a benefit,'' said Pinecrest Village Council Member Bob Ross. ``Undergrounding the power lines would be a place to start.''
The Florida Public Service Commission regulates most of Florida's electric utilities. The commission held hearings about FPL's rate proposal Thursday at the Miami Science Museum in Coconut Grove and the Broward County Main Library in Fort Lauderdale. It held hearings Friday at the North Dade Regional Library and in Plantation.
announcements, rants and meeting notes from grassroots organizing in the Northeast Everglades
Thursday, August 6, 2009
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
[updated 9/4/09] EAGLE NATIONAL SECURITY TRAINING CENTER PROPOSAL in Highlands County, FL... Upcoming Meetings
From Highlands Today: "By 2010, if Seth Ellis gets his way, Venus will become known as a live-fire training center for the military, homeland security, local police, even foreign governments. Ellis appeared Tuesday at the Highlands County Commission meeting, requesting expedited permitting for Eagle National Security Training Center, a 7,700-acre expanse near the Glades County border."
Mark your calendars:
OCTOBER 6th
The Highland County PLANNING AND ZONING Board voted August 11, 2009 to suggest approval of the Eagle Training Center (ETC).. Their suggestion will be voted on by the County Commission at a public meeting, October 6, at 9am. [Sept 15 meeting ETC agenda item was switched to the Oct 6 meeting]
There is also a Highlands County Board of County Commissioners' (HCBCC) Land Use Change hearing August 18, which people are encouraged to attend. This Eagle Land Use agenda item may be moved to the October 6 meeting, but we feel it is important to attend both and show the HCBCC that there is growing opposition.
So mark your calenders and plan a visit to one of the most beautiful rural areas left in South Florida's greater Everglades watershed, habitat for the last Florida Panther and Black Bear.
WHAT:
The upcoming meetings are to create a new zoning category and land use changes to allow the building of the Eagle National Security Training Center in southwest Highlands County. Specifically, a 6,000 foot airstrip, helipad, 2,000 acre free fire zone, 5 story building, 25 single family homes, a dormitory for 1,000 trainees, 100 multi family residences, 2 - 250 foot training towers and 950,000 square feet of buildings for lodging, recreation, welcome center, operational and administrative buildings up to three stories.
WHERE:
Highlands County Government Center
501 South Commerce,
Sebring, FL (in Downtown Sebring)
HCBCC Meetings start at 9:00 AM
Public Comment will be allowed following discussion on the project..
FOR MORE INFO:
Online articles at
http://www.newssun.com/0707-eb-county-eagle-develeopment-problems
http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2008/jul/16/161335/la-war-games-training-center-proposed-near-venus/
http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2009/aug/14/la-venus-neighbors-to-protest-war-games-facility/
For details call Planning & Zoning Dept., ask to speak with County Planner Don Hanna: (863) 402-6650
You can also have your comment included on public record by sending an email to Jodie Thayer: Jthayer@hcbcc.org and Mark J. Hill: MHILL@hcbcc.org
------------------------------------------
If you cannot attend meetings, please send emails and phone calls to Commissioners:
Barbara Stewart: bstewart@hcbcc.org
Don Bates: dbates@strato.net
Jeff Carlson : jcarlson@hcbcc.org 863-382-4141
Guy Maxcy: g.maxcy@themaxcygroup.com 863-385-7755W 863-385-1484H
Ed Stokes 863-655-0079, 863-402-6515
Mark your calendars:
OCTOBER 6th
The Highland County PLANNING AND ZONING Board voted August 11, 2009 to suggest approval of the Eagle Training Center (ETC).. Their suggestion will be voted on by the County Commission at a public meeting, October 6, at 9am. [Sept 15 meeting ETC agenda item was switched to the Oct 6 meeting]
There is also a Highlands County Board of County Commissioners' (HCBCC) Land Use Change hearing August 18, which people are encouraged to attend. This Eagle Land Use agenda item may be moved to the October 6 meeting, but we feel it is important to attend both and show the HCBCC that there is growing opposition.
So mark your calenders and plan a visit to one of the most beautiful rural areas left in South Florida's greater Everglades watershed, habitat for the last Florida Panther and Black Bear.
WHAT:
The upcoming meetings are to create a new zoning category and land use changes to allow the building of the Eagle National Security Training Center in southwest Highlands County. Specifically, a 6,000 foot airstrip, helipad, 2,000 acre free fire zone, 5 story building, 25 single family homes, a dormitory for 1,000 trainees, 100 multi family residences, 2 - 250 foot training towers and 950,000 square feet of buildings for lodging, recreation, welcome center, operational and administrative buildings up to three stories.
WHERE:
Highlands County Government Center
501 South Commerce,
Sebring, FL (in Downtown Sebring)
HCBCC Meetings start at 9:00 AM
Public Comment will be allowed following discussion on the project..
FOR MORE INFO:
Online articles at
http://www.newssun.com/0707-eb-county-eagle-develeopment-problems
http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2008/jul/16/161335/la-war-games-training-center-proposed-near-venus/
http://www2.highlandstoday.com/content/2009/aug/14/la-venus-neighbors-to-protest-war-games-facility/
For details call Planning & Zoning Dept., ask to speak with County Planner Don Hanna: (863) 402-6650
You can also have your comment included on public record by sending an email to Jodie Thayer: Jthayer@hcbcc.org and Mark J. Hill: MHILL@hcbcc.org
------------------------------------------
If you cannot attend meetings, please send emails and phone calls to Commissioners:
Barbara Stewart: bstewart@hcbcc.org
Don Bates: dbates@strato.net
Jeff Carlson : jcarlson@hcbcc.org 863-382-4141
Guy Maxcy: g.maxcy@themaxcygroup.com 863-385-7755W 863-385-1484H
Ed Stokes 863-655-0079, 863-402-6515
Appellate Bond set at $10,000 for FPL opponent;
Supporters seek to raise money for her release and spread awareness about Barley Barber Swamp
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE, 7/27/09
Contact: Everglades Earth First!, evergladesearthfirst@gmail.com
Stuart, FL—Following a sentence of 90 days for her act of civil disobedience in Barley Barber Swamp, Martin County Judge Stewart Hershey continues to punish environmental activist Stevie Lynn Lowe for taking her case to trial by setting an exorbitant appellate bond of $10,000. Lowe has received the longest sentence to date out of nearly 50 arrests from recent protests against FPL in the Treasure Coast area.
Unlike other Everglades activists arrested for civil disobedience, Lowe was found Not Guilty of Trespassing in Barley Barber Swamp by a jury on Thursday of last week. She was sentenced nonetheless based on a lingering Resisting Arrest charge accompanying the unsubstantiated Trespass allegation. Her attorney began the process to appeal the guilty verdict and the sentence immediately following the trial.
This Monday Lowe was back in front of Judge Hershey for an appellant bond, expecting a worse case scenario of $3-5000. In similar trials last year against FPL in Palm Beach County, most FPL opponents were found guilty by a jury of two to three misdemeanor charges related to blockading a proposed power plant construction road in Loxahatchee (on the scandal-ridden Palm Beach Aggregates site). Two of these 18 protestors who took their cases to trial were sentenced to jail time—30 and 60 days—due to their prior arrest records, according to the court. Lowe has no known prior convictions on her record.
A portion of the funds needed for the bond are currently available through fundraising that occurred earlier this year immediately following the arrests at Barley Barber. But after court costs and legal fees from various court proceedings, several thousand is still needed to secure an appellate bond for Lowe.
“Stevie’s bitter victory in court last week was a step towards justice for South Florida’s unique environment. Through civil disobedience actions like hers, people around the world are beginning to know about the threat FPL poses to places like Barley Barber Swamp,” said Everglades Earth First! organizer Russell McSpadden. “Now that FPL has failed to establish ownership of Barley Barber, we are planning to host a series of canoe trips into the waterway. “
“That place [Barley Barber] is coming to represent a global turning point in the battle against energy giants like FPL.”
Everglades Earth First! will soon be coordinating outings to the swamp for members of the public and media. Please get in touch to find out more details about the trips. According to FPL’s own promotional material on the visitor boardwalk, regional waterways including Barley Barber “served as important military transportation and exploration routes,” leaving a reasonable person to safely believe that the unique area is a waterway intended to be used and protected for the people of Florida and the U.S.
For earlier reports, photos and videos related to Barley Barber, please visit the following sights:
Background and legal updates- www.EvergladesEarthFirst.org
Recent video footage from inside Barley Barber- www.youtube.com/watch?v=pUSjf4sdLNI
Recent photos- www.flickr.com/photos/40739822@N03/
Protest news footage- http://www.wikio.com/video/757986
Background on Barley Barber- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barley_Barber_Swamp
xxx
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE, 7/27/09
Contact: Everglades Earth First!, evergladesearthfirst@gmail.com
Stuart, FL—Following a sentence of 90 days for her act of civil disobedience in Barley Barber Swamp, Martin County Judge Stewart Hershey continues to punish environmental activist Stevie Lynn Lowe for taking her case to trial by setting an exorbitant appellate bond of $10,000. Lowe has received the longest sentence to date out of nearly 50 arrests from recent protests against FPL in the Treasure Coast area.
Unlike other Everglades activists arrested for civil disobedience, Lowe was found Not Guilty of Trespassing in Barley Barber Swamp by a jury on Thursday of last week. She was sentenced nonetheless based on a lingering Resisting Arrest charge accompanying the unsubstantiated Trespass allegation. Her attorney began the process to appeal the guilty verdict and the sentence immediately following the trial.
This Monday Lowe was back in front of Judge Hershey for an appellant bond, expecting a worse case scenario of $3-5000. In similar trials last year against FPL in Palm Beach County, most FPL opponents were found guilty by a jury of two to three misdemeanor charges related to blockading a proposed power plant construction road in Loxahatchee (on the scandal-ridden Palm Beach Aggregates site). Two of these 18 protestors who took their cases to trial were sentenced to jail time—30 and 60 days—due to their prior arrest records, according to the court. Lowe has no known prior convictions on her record.
A portion of the funds needed for the bond are currently available through fundraising that occurred earlier this year immediately following the arrests at Barley Barber. But after court costs and legal fees from various court proceedings, several thousand is still needed to secure an appellate bond for Lowe.
“Stevie’s bitter victory in court last week was a step towards justice for South Florida’s unique environment. Through civil disobedience actions like hers, people around the world are beginning to know about the threat FPL poses to places like Barley Barber Swamp,” said Everglades Earth First! organizer Russell McSpadden. “Now that FPL has failed to establish ownership of Barley Barber, we are planning to host a series of canoe trips into the waterway. “
“That place [Barley Barber] is coming to represent a global turning point in the battle against energy giants like FPL.”
Everglades Earth First! will soon be coordinating outings to the swamp for members of the public and media. Please get in touch to find out more details about the trips. According to FPL’s own promotional material on the visitor boardwalk, regional waterways including Barley Barber “served as important military transportation and exploration routes,” leaving a reasonable person to safely believe that the unique area is a waterway intended to be used and protected for the people of Florida and the U.S.
For earlier reports, photos and videos related to Barley Barber, please visit the following sights:
Background and legal updates- www.EvergladesEarthFirst.org
Recent video footage from inside Barley Barber- www.youtube.com/watch?v=pUSjf4sdLNI
Recent photos- www.flickr.com/photos/40739822@N03/
Protest news footage- http://www.wikio.com/video/757986
Background on Barley Barber- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barley_Barber_Swamp
xxx
Monday, July 27, 2009
IS THE FLORIDA GOVERNOR AND THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION IN BED WITH FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT
News for Immediate Release
Date: 24 JUL 2009
CONTACT
Email: Support@SaporitoEnergyConsultants.com
Website: SaporitoEnergyConsultants.com
The Florida Power and Light Company (FPL) is petitioning the Florida Public Service Commission (PSC) for a whopping $1.3-billion dollar rate increase at a time when the U.S. economy is experiencing a devastating recessionary collapse across all sectors. Recently the PSC held service hearings around the state seeking public comments on FPL’s rate increase. But where was Charlie Crist, the Florida Governor during these PSC hearings? Crist was a no-show and failed to support Florida residents in seeking lower electric rates from FPL. However, Crist did invite the FPL Group Chief Executive Officer, Lewis Hay to attend his wedding late last year! Crist is also seen in an FPL video during Hay’s announcement of a solar plant in Florida. See, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rl-m6e08DY
Then you have one of the PSC’s Commissioners, Katrina McMurrian who accepted an invitation sent by the Electric Power Research Institute asking McMurrian to serve on an advisory group on smart grids and energy efficiency topics that form part of FPL’s rationale for increased rates.
Finally, its noted here that Crist appointed PSC Commissioner Nathan Skop – but Skop previously worked at FPL Energy – a subsidiary of FPL Group. According to Thomas Saporito, president of Saporito Energy Consultants, Inc.
“It certainly appears to me that Governor Crist and certain PSC Commissioners have a very cozy relationship with FPL at a time when FPL is seeking an unprecedented $1.3-billion dollar rate increase. The State Attorney’s Office should investigate.” Saporito said.
>>> End of release <<<
Date: 24 JUL 2009
CONTACT
Email: Support@SaporitoEnergyConsultants.com
Website: SaporitoEnergyConsultants.com
The Florida Power and Light Company (FPL) is petitioning the Florida Public Service Commission (PSC) for a whopping $1.3-billion dollar rate increase at a time when the U.S. economy is experiencing a devastating recessionary collapse across all sectors. Recently the PSC held service hearings around the state seeking public comments on FPL’s rate increase. But where was Charlie Crist, the Florida Governor during these PSC hearings? Crist was a no-show and failed to support Florida residents in seeking lower electric rates from FPL. However, Crist did invite the FPL Group Chief Executive Officer, Lewis Hay to attend his wedding late last year! Crist is also seen in an FPL video during Hay’s announcement of a solar plant in Florida. See, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rl-m6e08DY
Then you have one of the PSC’s Commissioners, Katrina McMurrian who accepted an invitation sent by the Electric Power Research Institute asking McMurrian to serve on an advisory group on smart grids and energy efficiency topics that form part of FPL’s rationale for increased rates.
Finally, its noted here that Crist appointed PSC Commissioner Nathan Skop – but Skop previously worked at FPL Energy – a subsidiary of FPL Group. According to Thomas Saporito, president of Saporito Energy Consultants, Inc.
“It certainly appears to me that Governor Crist and certain PSC Commissioners have a very cozy relationship with FPL at a time when FPL is seeking an unprecedented $1.3-billion dollar rate increase. The State Attorney’s Office should investigate.” Saporito said.
>>> End of release <<<
Friday, July 24, 2009
State Attorney unable to establish FPL ownership of Barley Barber in Trial;
Martin County comes down hard on swamp defendant Stevie Lowe despite Not Guilty verdict
For more info, contact: EvergladesEarthFirst@gmail.com
[See more photos at: http://www.flickr.com/photos/40739822@N03/
Stuart, FL—Today’s victory against Florida Power & Light (FPL) was bittersweet for Stevie Lynn Lowe. The jury returned a ‘not-guilty’ verdict for the charge of Trespassing on the Barley Barber swamp, indicating that State Prosecutors, Maria Zamora were unable to establish clear property boundaries for the old-growth swamp claimed as private property by FPL . Yet, in a confusing twist of events, a verdict of ‘guilty’ was returned for the charge of Resisting Without Violence (a charge which rarely stands on its own.)
Everglades Earth First! (EEF!), the local group with which Lowe was a part of, celebrated the outcome as a victory towards truly preserving Barley Barber swamp. At the opening of the Defense’s case, Lowe’s Public Defender, Jordan Dershaw, filed a motion for a Judgment of Acquittal (JOA) based on the fact that Barley Barber swamp is a recognized navigable waterway with documented historical use for transport and commerce and its current connectivity to the L-65 Canal, St. Lucie Canal and Lake Okeechobee. The presiding County Court Judge, Stuart Hershey, denied the JOA, prompting Dershaw to present the expert testimony of hydro-ecologist Dr. Sydney T. Bacchus to establish the presence of this public navigable waterway.
Dr. Bacchus is an expert scientific witness in legal cases and has worked for several government agencies dealing with the jurisdiction of waterways, including the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD). Judge Hershey expelled Dr. Bacchus’ testimony from the trial, refusing to allow the jury to hear the expert testimony for themselves. The Judge used highly questionable grounds, utilizing weak case-law interpretation provided by the Prosecution.
Despite these substantial setbacks, the jury still ruled in favor of Ms. Lowe on the charge of trespassing. To a packed courtroom, the Judge sentenced Lowe to ninety days on the remaining charge of Resisting (Arrest) Without Violence. Lowe, who has no prior criminal record, was also given a year of probation, almost one thousand dollars in court and investigation costs. Supporters considered the ninety days excessive given the fact that the jury found her not-guilty on the charge for which she was arrested.
“Its a real David and Goliath story. Stevie Lowe bravely stood up to one of the largest corporations in Florida and won. FPL is destroying the natural heritage of Martin County. We need to hold FPL accountable for their destruction of Barley Barber swamp. Stevie has put us on the right path,” commented Everglades Earth First! organizer Russell McSpadden outside the courtroom.
Citing that a co-defendant of Lowe’s plead out to Judge Hershey earlier this month for a 5 day sentence, supporters stated that Lowe was being punished for exercising her constitutional right to a trial by jury. Several new motions and an appeal for Lowe's release are pending.
“While Martin County has attempted to intimidate and suppress the voices of FPL’s opponents, we remain more committed than ever to protect the ancient swamp of Barley Barber for future generations.”
xxx
An Appeal for Barley Barber and an Appellate Bond for Stevie Lynn Lowe:
Today [7/23/09] Stevie Lynn Lowe went to trial for her actions to defend and save Barley Barber Swamp. Stevie faced the charges of trespassing into Barley Barber and for resisting arrest when she swam through the swamp, climbed a tall Swamp Maple and locked herself to the tree. At 3705 Megawatts, FPL’s Martin County Power Plant, which sits adjacent to Barley Barber is killing the wetlands through hydrologic disruption and pollution.
The Jury found Stevie no guilty of trespassing. Neither the State nor FPL could prove that the energy giant owns Barley Barber. This was a major victory. However, the charge of resisting arrest without violence, a misdemeanor, stuck. The Judge presiding over the case sentenced Stevie, who has no prior record, to 90 days in jail and a year probation for that single charge which rarely stands on its own. This excessive sentencing is an obvious attempt to stifle dissent.
We may need to raise approximately $5000 dollars to get Stevie out on appellate bond while we proceed to appeal several aspects of the case, including the excessive sentencing. The money raised for bond will eventually come back to us after the appeal process and will we used for future organizing and legal support for direct action in the swamps.
Please donate money:
-via PayPal at www.EvergladesEarthFirst.org
For more info, contact: EvergladesEarthFirst@gmail.com
[See more photos at: http://www.flickr.com/photos/40739822@N03/Stuart, FL—Today’s victory against Florida Power & Light (FPL) was bittersweet for Stevie Lynn Lowe. The jury returned a ‘not-guilty’ verdict for the charge of Trespassing on the Barley Barber swamp, indicating that State Prosecutors, Maria Zamora were unable to establish clear property boundaries for the old-growth swamp claimed as private property by FPL . Yet, in a confusing twist of events, a verdict of ‘guilty’ was returned for the charge of Resisting Without Violence (a charge which rarely stands on its own.)
Everglades Earth First! (EEF!), the local group with which Lowe was a part of, celebrated the outcome as a victory towards truly preserving Barley Barber swamp. At the opening of the Defense’s case, Lowe’s Public Defender, Jordan Dershaw, filed a motion for a Judgment of Acquittal (JOA) based on the fact that Barley Barber swamp is a recognized navigable waterway with documented historical use for transport and commerce and its current connectivity to the L-65 Canal, St. Lucie Canal and Lake Okeechobee. The presiding County Court Judge, Stuart Hershey, denied the JOA, prompting Dershaw to present the expert testimony of hydro-ecologist Dr. Sydney T. Bacchus to establish the presence of this public navigable waterway.
Dr. Bacchus is an expert scientific witness in legal cases and has worked for several government agencies dealing with the jurisdiction of waterways, including the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD). Judge Hershey expelled Dr. Bacchus’ testimony from the trial, refusing to allow the jury to hear the expert testimony for themselves. The Judge used highly questionable grounds, utilizing weak case-law interpretation provided by the Prosecution.
Despite these substantial setbacks, the jury still ruled in favor of Ms. Lowe on the charge of trespassing. To a packed courtroom, the Judge sentenced Lowe to ninety days on the remaining charge of Resisting (Arrest) Without Violence. Lowe, who has no prior criminal record, was also given a year of probation, almost one thousand dollars in court and investigation costs. Supporters considered the ninety days excessive given the fact that the jury found her not-guilty on the charge for which she was arrested.
“Its a real David and Goliath story. Stevie Lowe bravely stood up to one of the largest corporations in Florida and won. FPL is destroying the natural heritage of Martin County. We need to hold FPL accountable for their destruction of Barley Barber swamp. Stevie has put us on the right path,” commented Everglades Earth First! organizer Russell McSpadden outside the courtroom.
Citing that a co-defendant of Lowe’s plead out to Judge Hershey earlier this month for a 5 day sentence, supporters stated that Lowe was being punished for exercising her constitutional right to a trial by jury. Several new motions and an appeal for Lowe's release are pending.
“While Martin County has attempted to intimidate and suppress the voices of FPL’s opponents, we remain more committed than ever to protect the ancient swamp of Barley Barber for future generations.”
xxx
An Appeal for Barley Barber and an Appellate Bond for Stevie Lynn Lowe:
Today [7/23/09] Stevie Lynn Lowe went to trial for her actions to defend and save Barley Barber Swamp. Stevie faced the charges of trespassing into Barley Barber and for resisting arrest when she swam through the swamp, climbed a tall Swamp Maple and locked herself to the tree. At 3705 Megawatts, FPL’s Martin County Power Plant, which sits adjacent to Barley Barber is killing the wetlands through hydrologic disruption and pollution.
The Jury found Stevie no guilty of trespassing. Neither the State nor FPL could prove that the energy giant owns Barley Barber. This was a major victory. However, the charge of resisting arrest without violence, a misdemeanor, stuck. The Judge presiding over the case sentenced Stevie, who has no prior record, to 90 days in jail and a year probation for that single charge which rarely stands on its own. This excessive sentencing is an obvious attempt to stifle dissent.
We may need to raise approximately $5000 dollars to get Stevie out on appellate bond while we proceed to appeal several aspects of the case, including the excessive sentencing. The money raised for bond will eventually come back to us after the appeal process and will we used for future organizing and legal support for direct action in the swamps.
Please donate money:
-via PayPal at www.EvergladesEarthFirst.org
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)